Within the U.S., fluoride is taken into account the gold customary—regardless of identified dangers of thyroid disruption, IQ discount at excessive doses, and accumulation within the physique.
In the meantime, nano-hydroxyapatite—which doesn’t take up into the bloodstream—has been utilized in Japan and Europe for many years.
And nonetheless, most Individuals have by no means heard of it…
It’s known as nano-hydroxyapatite.
And for lots of people, the phrase “nano” is the place the dialog stops. Or, perhaps we misplaced you at “fluoride different.”
Which is simply too dangerous.
As a result of the science is extremely thrilling to me as a dentist of 40 years who, again in 1983, determined the potential advantage of fluoride was not well worth the danger, and went on to lift my three daughters with no single drop of fluoride.
A number of security evaluations—together with one from Europe’s prime unbiased toxicology panel—have discovered that nano-hydroxyapatite doesn’t take up into the physique, doesn’t harm DNA, and breaks down into the identical minerals your enamel are product of.
Simply this month, Europe’s prime security panel—the SCCS—up to date its advice on nano-hydroxyapatite after years of overview.
Whereas the SCCS doesn’t consider how effectively nano-HAP works, its up to date overview confirms the ingredient is secure to be used at concentrations far larger than beforehand allowed—to the tune of almost 3x in toothpaste and over 20x for mouthwash.
Who the heck is the SCCS, and why ought to their opinion matter? This isn’t industry-funded science—it’s unbiased, peer-reviewed, and publicly accessible. When the SCCS says one thing is secure, it means it’s handed one of many strictest security bars on the planet.
Within the U.S., if there’s no information proving hurt, it’s typically assumed secure. Harmless till confirmed responsible.
Within the EU, it’s the alternative: if security isn’t confirmed, it’s assumed dangerous. That’s why their findings truly imply one thing to me.
That is additionally why I look to European companies relating to security of whitening supplies. I wrote extra about this in a earlier publication.
So when the SCCS says nano-hydroxyapatite is secure, that’s after years of rigorous overview, public scrutiny, and re-evaluation each time new information emerges.
That mindset protects individuals—I simply want U.S. regulators shared it. Their conservative, precautionary mindset places public security first in a manner that needs to be the worldwide norm. I can dream, can’t I?
Maybe for this reason the U.S. has banned 11 beauty elements and the EU has banned over 1,300. (Sure, it’s loopy that oral care is regulated as a beauty!)
The SCCS has reviewed nano-HAP since 2016. Their newest replace displays almost a decade of ongoing information overview—precisely how science ought to work.
This replace confirms what we already knew: nano-hydroxyapatite helps reverse early cavities, ease sensitivity, and help your oral microbiome. And it’s secure for the remainder of your physique.
That is the toothpaste I take advantage of and co-formulated with nano-hydroxyapatite, together with a triple board licensed pediatric dentist. I’ve watched this arrest my granddaughter’s cavities. I’ve seen it ease ache with out including to the chemical load our children already carry greater than sufficient of. And I’ve seen research after research exhibiting that it performs simply as effectively—if not higher—than fluoride toothpaste.
Fluoride, in contrast, has been linked to thyroid disruption and decrease IQ scores in high-exposure areas—particularly regarding in younger youngsters. It really works when utilized topically (by way of toothpaste—NOT by way of ingestion by way of fluoridated water, by the way in which) BUT it builds up within the physique over time. That’s the place nano-HAP gives a wiser different—similar profit, fewer tradeoffs.
So how do we all know nano-hydroxyapatite is secure? Right here’s what the SCCS overview confirmed. Let’s break down precisely what the brand new report says—level by level.
- No genotoxicity: it doesn’t harm DNA.
- No irritation or irritation: even when utilized on to oral tissue.
- Negligible absorption: the particles don’t enter the bloodstream.
- No nano-specific danger when swallowed: they dissolve into calcium and phosphate within the abdomen (precisely what I’ve been saying for years).
And no, the SCCS discovered no indication that these particles cross the blood-brain barrier (there’s some misinformation floating round Instagram that claims this). I at all times say: sure, issues can get absorbed via the oral mucosa—however that’s precisely why this overview issues.
And when nano-hydroxyapatite dissolves within the abdomen, it turns into calcium and phosphate—minerals your physique already makes use of to construct bone, regulate cells, and preserve wholesome blood chemistry. Your physique is aware of precisely what to do with them.
Nano-silver, however, has been proven to persist in tissues and will intervene with intestine or mitochondrial perform. Some research recommend bioaccumulation dangers—particularly with frequent publicity. That’s why I don’t advocate nano-silver in toothpaste. It’s not biomimetic, and the dangers outweigh the advantages. I do know different dentists will disagree with me on this.
This aligns with what many people in useful dentistry have been advocating for years: that biomimetic supplies like nano-HAP will not be solely efficient, however extremely secure when used correctly.
The SCCS isn’t simply assured. They’re doubling down.
In a world the place so many merchandise make daring claims however include questionable elements, it’s deeply reassuring to have one which checks each containers: efficient and secure for the entire physique.
That is useful dentistry at its finest: not being so centered on the enamel that we neglect systemic well being as effectively.
And the truth that Europe’s most rigorous security panel simply backed it once more? That’s one thing to have fun.
-Dr. B
🧠 Sponsored by Masszymes – a complement I personally take
I speak so much about optimizing for well being—whether or not it’s your oral microbiome or your digestion. One product that’s been a staple in my very own routine for years is Masszymes.
Why it really works: It’s a high-potency enzyme mix that helps your physique digest protein extra effectively—particularly after huge meals, throughout journey, or when stress throws digestion off monitor.
The outcome? Higher nutrient absorption, much less bloating, and extra vitality from the meals you’re already consuming. 👉 Right here’s how I take advantage of Masszymes—and why I like to recommend it →Right here’s how I take advantage of Masszymes—and why I like to recommend it →
P.S. In the event you’ve made it this far—thanks.
I do know your inbox is crowded, and the truth that you select to spend time with me right here means so much. I write these emails as a result of I consider we want extra root-cause considering in dentistry—and since you deserve care that appears on the entire image, not simply the signs.
Additionally: one of the best ways to maintain your oral well being is to see your dentist. Have these conversations with them. Ask questions. Share what you’re studying.
And if that’s not touchdown—or for those who don’t really feel your dentist is open to the useful strategy—take a look at my Practical Dentist Listing. It’s there that will help you discover somebody who’s curious, collaborative, and dedicated to treating root causes.